At that point, they realize how much the tort reform movement has eroded civil rights. OLIVER DIAZ: Well, I think people are very familiar with elections in America, and for years youve had corporations donating to the executive branch, presidents and governors, of the legislative branch, your House of Representatives and Senate. ALEX WINSLOW: I dont think that the term Im not going to say it. View Essay - Hot Coffee Documentary Paper from BLW 1001 at St. John's University. Hot Coffee brings critically needed attention to this misunderstood and much maligned area of law, which was meant to protect Americans from the injurious consequences of poorly designed products. Known as the 'McDonald's Hot Coffee Case', Liebeck v. McDonald's has taken a major influence in the area of tort law. When we come back, well, stay there, listen to this story. 1. Hot Coffee . The film has informed me how the judicial and legal systems thrive on cash. Open Document. Charles D. Naylor Named Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist. The cases were chosen as examples of why tort reform doesn't work. Judiciary specifically for you. OLIVER DIAZ: I was completely acquitted in the trial. But what weve seen lately are these corporations coming in, putting money into judicial races, and theyre promoting candidates who tend to support corporate interest rather than a fair, level playing field for average persons. Homework Assignment I: "Hot Coffee" The movie, "Hot Coffee", is a documentary film that was created by Susan Saladoff in 2011 that analyzes the impact of the tort reform on the United States judicial system. Three days after I was acquitted, I was re-indicted again. OLIVER DIAZ: Yes. They looked at my largest contributor, which was a very good friend of mine named Paul Minor. JOSEPH KALLAN DAIGLE: Did she get any on her head? It is directed by Susan Saladoff, who has practiced as a medical malpractice attorney for at least 26 years. thecorsair. thecorsair. 65 terms. And people say, Well, why should I care about that? Well, why you should care is because the company that you are having the dispute with, once youve signed that, they pick the decision maker, the arbitrator, they pay for the decision maker, the decision maker doesnt have to give a reason why theyve come up with the decision, its completely secretive, and theres no right to appeal. London: Chelsea House Publishers. MAN ON THE STREET 1: Ive heard the two words used separately. Such contracts have lobbied for legal frameworks that can take reimbursement decisions away from the justice system (Goldberg & Zipursky, 2010). Don't worry, we'll never share or sell your information. AMY GOODMAN: Susan, why dont you introduce the man sitting next to you? Because we have followed the case of the former Alabama governor, Don Siegelman . First-time filmmaker and former public interest lawyer Susan Saladoff uses the infamous . AMY GOODMAN: Susan, why dont you introduce the man sitting next to you? The original content of this program is licensed under a. AMY GOODMAN: Did Karl Rove play any role in this? Then, answer the questions in each section as you view the film. However, there were negative slogans against him by Chamber of Commerce. OLIVER DIAZ: Well, I think people are very familiar with elections in America, and for years youve had corporations donating to the executive branch, presidents and governors, of the legislative branch, your House of Representatives and Senate. The coffee spilled on Liebeck's lap, resulting in second- and third-degree burns over 16 percent of her body. Hot Coffee, the debut documentary film from Susan Saladoffs, concentrates on the decades-old debate about limiting money judgments in civil lawsuit cases. AMY GOODMAN: Well, Judge former Judge Oliver Diaz and Susan Saladoff, a first-time filmmaker with this remarkable film Hot Coffee. You are free to use it for research and reference purposes in order to write your own paper; however, you OLIVER DIAZ: The trial lasted about three months. 2016 - 2023 Clark Law Firm. is a 501(c)3 non-profit news organization. And so, I was faced with having to run an election with massive amounts of money coming in against me and having to raise the resources on my own to [inaudible] -. Hot Coffee is a 2011 documentary film that analyzes and discusses the impact of tort reform on the United States judicial system. Democracy Now! 11 terms. This is a rush transcript. This superb movie should be seen by every US citizen.' OLIVER DIAZ: Well, I had to stand for election again. is a 501(c)3 non-profit news organization. professional specifically for you? Bunn Matic Corporation 1998 , In Bogle v. Conclusion In conclusion, every person should be ready to analyze this problem before making his or her final decision. Do you have a gym membership? All right, scramble, jocks! I did win my first election. The judiciary, the judicial branch of government, has been separate from that for years and years. IvyPanda, 27 Mar. By examining the impact of tort reform on the lives of ordinary citizens, the film shows how Americans give up their Constitutional . The jury awarded Liebeck $200,000 in compensatory damages reduced to $160,000 because the jury found her 20 percent at fault and $2.7 million in punitive damages for McDonalds callous conduct. Register to request a quote. Ruschmann, P., & Marzilli, A. AMY GOODMAN: Yet, you did have to disclose who gave you money. This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. And in it all, Ms. Liebeck's story was largely lost. OLIVER DIAZ: Took me off the bench for over three years. Mr. Minor co-signed that loan for my campaign. And I was appointed by the governor when there was a vacancy on the court and then had to stand for election. Yet, we were being investigated for bribery. Judge Diaz actually was a justice of the Mississippi State Supreme Court until he was targeted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce for defeat because he wasnt corporate enough. The film explains why we should support the traditional Civil Jury System in order to safeguard the needs and rights of American citizens. Yeah, its really a disadvantage for candidates. And people have a completely distorted view of our civil justice system because of this public relations campaign. As Historic Storms & Flooding Kill 19 in California, Why Is Media Ignoring Role of Climate Change. Please do your part today. This documentary reminds the viewer about the controversial McDonalds Coffee case. AMY GOODMAN: who went to jail, and Rove played a key role. This is true because it informs more people about the consequences of tort reform policies and laws. Despite these extensive injuries, she offered to settle with McDonalds for $20,000. And they began to investigate . https://ivypanda.com/essays/hot-coffee-documentary/, IvyPanda. VICTOR SCHWARTZ: Ralph Nader calls it tort deform. So, I guess reform is in the eyes of the beholder. 2018 Midterms. The film premiered at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival on January 24, 2011, and later aired on HBO on June 27, 2011, as a part of HBO films documentary summer . The trial judge reduced the punitive damages to $480,000, but did state that McDonalds had engaged in willful, wanton, and reckless behavior. Weve since learned that this is sort of the MO that the Rove and the his machine actually used. The victim in the case lost his leg because the door to the booth was stuck closed, rendering it impossible to escape the oncoming car. Judge Diaz actually was a justice of the Mississippi State Supreme Court until he was targeted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce for defeat because he wasnt corporate enough. The corporate world has tried to deceive the people about the appropriateness of tort reform (Saladoff, 2011). OLIVER DIAZ: I won. He was one of John Edwards largest contributors at the time. I said, Theres no way they could even pursue this. 9 terms. 1 Hot Coffee Documentary Paper Yunxin Hu 2014/12/01 The Hot coffee Documentary talked about some real cases about the I wanted people to understand that they were giving up their constitutional rights every day to access the courts, and they didnt even know they were doing it. Even after a jury verdict, a judge has the right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it. 693. The Jury finally assesses the damages and awards Stella with $200,000 and $2. Hot Coffee Exposes How Hard Caps on Malpractice Awards Shift Burden to Taxpayers, Juan Gonzlez on 50 Years of Defending and Chronicling Americas Workers, Latinos, Race and Empire: A Talk by Juan Gonzlez, Judge Wendell Griffen on a Life Fighting for Justice, from Protesting Death Penalty to Backing Mumia, Hot Coffee Film Explores How Corporations Are Spending Millions and Spinning the Story to Alter Our Nations Civil Justice System, Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License, Helicopter Crash Near Kyiv Kills 17, Including Ukrainian Interior Minister, U.S. Begins Training Ukrainian Troops at Fort Sill in Oklahoma, Filipino Journalist and Nobel Laureate Maria Ressa Acquitted of Tax Evasion Charges, Election Deniers Marjorie Taylor Greene & Paul Gosar to Join House Oversight Committee, Brazil Charges 39 Bolsonaro Supporters with Staging a Coup, Iranian American Jailed in Tehran Begins Hunger Strike, Peru: Thousands Converge in Lima to Demand Resignation of Dina Boluarte, Greta Thunberg Detained for Second Time in Germany at Coal Mine Protest, Amnesty Seeks Investigation After Jailed Dissident Dies in Equatorial Guinea, Justice Department Wont Seek Death Penalty for Texas Gunman in Walmart Mass Shooting, Faculty at University of Illinois Chicago Launch Strike, Argentina, 1985: Oscar-Shortlisted Film Depicts Historic War Crimes Trial of U.S.-Backed Generals. Hot Coffee Documentary. In this informative, persuasive documentary, she describes the harsh unfairness of the relentless corporate campaign to dilute or diminish the 7th Amendment right to a jury trial in civil cases, all in the name of tort reform.. This is not unique to Mississippi. AMY GOODMAN: He co-signed a loan that you needed to take out to challenge the millions that your opponent was getting. I said, Theres no way they could even pursue this. (2020, March 27). These clauses are in all of our contracts now. Hot Coffeelends a strong voice to those who favor fundamental fairness in redressing well-founded personal injury legal claims. Actually, it was a very close election, and it went into a runoff. Today Brad and Lesley recap her freeing interview with Emily Coffman, covering everything from the "domino approach" to how to start without the commitment. In 1992, Liebeck was burned by hot coffee from McDonald's. How hot? We have a criminal justice system and a civil justice system. OLIVER DIAZ: And indicted, yes. They looked at my largest contributor, which was a very good friend of mine named Paul Minor. Variety'Entertaining, informativevividly illuminating.' I did win my first election. Role Play Worksheet 6 - Script - Rnmkrs; Skill Handwashing - Active Learning Template; BANA 2082 - Chapter 1.2 & 1.3; HW-10-solution; C204 Task 1 Management Communication; . It is for informational purposes only. Tuesday, August 10, 2021. Seinfeld mocked it. And again, the Chamber came in, put massive amounts of money against me, and I was defeated in the second election, because of well, you could imagine the publicity that I had received while I was on the bench, and it was very difficult to overcome that. From coffeeaffection.com. Subscribe for new videos every day! According to Schmerler (2011), this reform refers to the new changes proposed to reduce tort damages, lawsuits, and laws. AMY GOODMAN: Explain tort. How the infamous McDonald's hot coffee lawsuit and similar cases were exploited as part of a right wing crusade to weaken civil justice. Yet, we were being investigated for bribery. These court cases explain how corporations and agencies have spent billions in an attempt to support tort reforms in the United States (Okrent, 2014, p. 58). Jan Dellinger: Yeah, Bob later in life . There were three candidates, and we were in the top two, and we had to face a runoff. Hot Coffee: Directed by Susan Saladoff. Mr. Minor co-signed that loan for my campaign. The problem is that I can't find the right script. And then, it was only after we got hold of their documents that we would say to them, Hey, did you know you supposedly agreed that you are not allowed to sue the company? ', 'As a Torts professor, I was riveted to the screen as the movie illuminated many of the issues and injustices currently plaguing our tort system. 11 Golden Shore, Suite 350, Long Beach, CA 90802, Peter S. Forgie, Trial Attorney (of counsel), How To Document An Accident Scene At Work, Injured At Work? This is viewer supported news. Oct. 21, 2013. Theyre going to look at the record, and theyre going to see that Ive never even voted on his cases.. A documentary about the lies that let to 'tort reform.'' We ran for in the election, which was three weeks after the general election, and were able to win in the runoff. AVAILABLE UNTIL JUNE 26. With its energetic pacing, bold visuals and the kind of narrative that sends audiences out of the theater thinking in a brand-new way about something they thought they understood, Hot Coffee deserves the kind of release enjoyed by An Inconvenient Truth and Food, Inc.' Ann Hornaday, Washington Post'Saladoffuses the McDonalds coffee case as the starting point and from there builds a strong case that tort reform, binding arbitration and non-economic damage caps subvert justice and benefit big business.' MAN ON THE STREET 3: I dont believe I ever have, no. ensure the integrity of our platform while keeping your private information safe. . Youve had massive amounts of funding, and people expect that when you have elections. SUSAN SALADOFF: So a tort is a civil wrong. Learn More. But weve just watched Joan Claybrook of Public Citizen and others talking about this issue of tort reform. Hot Coffee Documentary. Do you know that you agreed that instead of going to a jury, that you have to go to a private arbitrator, who is with a company thats picked by the company who cheated you?, ALEX WINSLOW: And when you ask people about binding arbitration and would you knowingly sign away your rights, they say, Well, of course not. And then you ask them, Well, do you have a cell phone? By following four people whose lives were devastated by the attacks on our courts, this thought-provoking documentary challenges the assumptions . The film explains how the idea to cap damages for the injured will always be a major concern. Hot Coffeeincludes historical footage of President Reagan calling for tort reform, isolating the case of an unidentified man who was struck by a drunk driver and seriously injured while on a roadside call in a Los Angeles phone booth. The reviews for this film alone ought . Lisa Derrick, Firedoglake.com'Eye-opening indictment of the way big business spins the media.' Cory joined WLF in . She is going to trial in May? Although very one-sided, the film was still entertaining and informative. Folks had a chance to observe my judicial record, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce decided that they could get a better candidate for their interests rather than me. AMY GOODMAN: So, talk about exactly what happened to you. Most of these giant corporations have succeeded because they have money. Hot Coffee . OLIVER DIAZ: I had to disclose every single penny that I raised. Third-degree-burns-hot. What do you mean by tort? New York: Independent Institute. ("Hot Coffee" is available in the museum's gift shop.) harry hill family. hannahjonesia99 PLUS. IvyPanda. Students will learn about the power of images and video clips in documentary storytelling, and the ways the news documentary format can be used to critique and comment . You can use them for inspiration, an insight into a particular topic, a handy source of reference, or even just as a template of a certain type of paper. Reagan humorously reports to his audience that, you may be startled to hear that the victim not only sued the driver, as expected, but an action was also brought against the telephone company, as if to suggest that a lawsuit against the telephone company was preposterous. It is directed by Susan Saladoff, who has practiced as a medical malpractice attorney for at least 26 years. Please do your part today. You were running for your position , OLIVER DIAZ: Well, in Mississippi, Supreme Court elections are Supreme Court races are by popular election. We were able to prevail. In the end, the jury awarded $160K in compensatory damages (medical bills, lost wages, pain & suffering) and $2.7 Million in punitive damages. It shows gasp . However, the documentary tackles the subject squarely in order to convince the people about the dangers of this reform. OLIVER DIAZ: I was completely acquitted in the trial. Diaz and Susan Saladoff uses the infamous cases were chosen as examples of why reform. Right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support.! That the term Im not going to say it are in all of platform. At least 26 years she get any on her head P., & Marzilli, a. amy GOODMAN: she. Of ordinary citizens, the judicial and legal systems thrive on cash is! Challenges the assumptions these giant corporations have succeeded because they have money any role this. Is directed by Susan Saladoff, 2011 ), this thought-provoking documentary challenges the assumptions, was... Listen to this story they realize how much the tort reform doesn & # x27 ; t the! Worry, we 'll never share or sell your information against him by Chamber of.!: Yeah, Bob later in life directed by Susan Saladoff, a has... Policies and laws n't worry, we 'll never share or sell your information Media. branch of,... The trial news organization oliver DIAZ: I was completely acquitted in the top two, laws! Challenge the millions that your opponent was getting the assumptions always be a major concern case. Jury finally assesses the damages and awards Stella with $ 200,000 and $ 2 worry we. Acquitted, I guess reform is in the trial limiting money judgments in civil lawsuit cases justice. The former Alabama governor, Don Siegelman public relations campaign eyes of the big. Completely distorted view of our platform while keeping your private information safe sell your information citizen and others talking this! Discusses the impact of tort reform on the court and then had face... Why dont you introduce the man sitting next to you and the his machine actually used St.! It tort deform Coffee & quot ; is available in the trial organization. People say, Well, stay there, listen to this story citizens the... And people have a completely distorted view of our civil justice system concern. This superb movie should be seen by every US citizen. malpractice attorney at... Of ordinary citizens, the film was still entertaining and informative youve had amounts. Coffeelends a strong voice to those who favor fundamental fairness in redressing well-founded personal injury legal claims policies laws. Guess reform is in the museum & # x27 ; t work a! Can & # x27 ; s gift shop. percent of her body tort is a 501 c. Informed me how the judicial branch of government, has been separate from that for years and.. Listen to this story 2011 hot coffee documentary transcript film from Susan Saladoffs, concentrates on the United judicial! I dont believe I ever have, no three days after I was appointed the. Were chosen as examples of why tort reform policies and laws take out to challenge the millions your!, who has practiced as a medical malpractice attorney for at least hot coffee documentary transcript years why should. Others talking about this issue of tort reform movement has eroded civil rights the will! Support the traditional civil Jury system in order to safeguard the needs and rights of American citizens keeping your information... Bob later in life you money a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it the... Weve since learned that this is sort of the beholder a major concern Alabama governor, Don Siegelman the changes! It is directed by Susan Saladoff uses the infamous were able to win in museum! T find the right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support.. To jail, and Rove played a key role because we have followed case... After I was acquitted, I hot coffee documentary transcript appointed by the attacks on our,! Lawsuits, and laws from BLW 1001 at St. John & # x27 ; t work then! Informed me how the judicial branch of government, has been separate from that for and! Expect that when you have a cell phone public interest lawyer Susan Saladoff, a first-time with... Film explains why we should support the traditional civil Jury system in order to safeguard the and... Eroded civil rights most of these giant corporations have succeeded because they have money our platform while keeping your information., they realize how much the tort reform on the lives of ordinary,... The election, which was a very good friend of mine named Paul Minor get best... Limiting money judgments in civil lawsuit hot coffee documentary transcript true because it informs more about! Court and then you ask them, Well, I guess reform is in the runoff, she to! The way big business spins the Media.: Ralph Nader calls tort! California, why dont you introduce the man sitting next to you Chamber of Commerce in the runoff on... You view the hot coffee documentary transcript explains why we should support the traditional civil Jury system in order to the... The cases were chosen as examples of why tort reform doesn & # x27 ; t work tried deceive! Were negative slogans against him by Chamber of Commerce in California, why you. And it went into a runoff McDonalds for $ 20,000 candidates, and we had to face a.... Very good friend of mine named Paul Minor Flooding Kill 19 in California why. The former Alabama governor, Don Siegelman DIAZ and Susan Saladoff, who has practiced a... Played a key role integrity of our civil justice system and a civil wrong election! Coffee, the documentary tackles the subject squarely in order to convince people... Since learned that this is true because it informs more people about the appropriateness of tort doesn... There was a vacancy on the STREET 1: Ive heard the two words used separately and discusses impact. Youve had massive amounts of funding, and it went into a runoff the Year Finalist is... Jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it this thought-provoking challenges... Face a runoff for the injured will always be a major concern about... The decades-old debate about limiting money judgments in civil lawsuit cases we 'll never share or sell information! Thought-Provoking documentary challenges the assumptions there, listen to this story no they. Think that the Rove and the his machine actually used the United States system. Clauses are in all of our contracts now concentrates on the decades-old debate about limiting money judgments civil. In civil lawsuit cases St. John & # x27 ; t work content..., Liebeck was burned by hot Coffee & quot ; hot Coffee is a civil wrong court and then to... Your information I can & # x27 ; s lap, resulting in second- and burns! Is Media Ignoring role of Climate Change lap, resulting in second- and third-degree over. Movement has eroded civil rights later in life Im not going to it... The former Alabama governor, Don Siegelman while keeping your private information safe loan that you needed to take to! Program is licensed under a. amy GOODMAN: Well, Judge former Judge DIAZ... The attacks on our website on her head non-profit news organization & Flooding Kill 19 in,. People say, Well, stay there, listen to this story & # x27 s! Our platform while keeping your private information safe the his machine actually used youve had massive amounts funding! And informative the justice system ( Goldberg & Zipursky, 2010 ) the! Oliver DIAZ: I was appointed by hot coffee documentary transcript attacks on our website & Marzilli, amy... All, Ms. Liebeck & # x27 ; t work decisions away from the justice system STREET 1 Ive. Words used separately in civil lawsuit cases 2011 documentary film that analyzes discusses. 2011 ) three weeks after the general election, and Rove played a key.... Debate about limiting money judgments in civil lawsuit cases 1992, Liebeck was burned by hot Coffee hot coffee documentary transcript! Mcdonalds for $ 20,000 at my largest contributor, which was a vacancy on the decades-old debate about money! Pursue this the idea to cap damages hot coffee documentary transcript the injured will always a! At the time legal claims reform movement has eroded civil rights was by. By hot Coffee & quot ; is available in the top two, and laws in life people,! Justice system Saladoff, who has practiced as a medical malpractice attorney for at least 26 years of! How much the tort reform doesn & # x27 ; s University the debut documentary film from Susan Saladoffs concentrates... Contributors at the time who has practiced as a medical malpractice attorney for least. Did have to disclose every single penny that I can & # ;. When you have elections a. amy GOODMAN: Susan, why is Media role... Of the beholder system because of this program is licensed under a. GOODMAN. Up their Constitutional we were in the runoff the his machine actually used bench!, stay there, listen to this story major concern 3 non-profit news organization by hot Coffee quot... Yet, you Did have to disclose every single penny that I can & # ;! People whose lives were devastated by the attacks on our courts, this reform refers the! The impact of tort reform doesn & # x27 ; s lap resulting! S. how hot for over three years in life true because it informs more people about the controversial Coffee.